| | |

AI Is Changing Search. Wil Reynolds’ Take: Being Visible Isn’t the Same as Being Choosen

AI is changing how people search, but we’re still in the early innings of this technology and adoption. At BlueHuki, we’re seeing far fewer conversions from AI platforms than from traditional search today, so we don’t believe businesses should abandon proven channels to chase AI visibility.

The best uses of AI in marketing is to prepare for where search is going while continuing to invest in what is driving customers now and to measure success not just by whether you’re visible, but whether people actually trust and choose you.

Learning Lessons from Women in Tech SEO Fest (WTSFest) in Philadelphia

Our Founder & CEO, Dr. Heather Presler, recently attended WTSFest Philadelphia. the Women in Tech SEO’s conference bringing together experts in SEO, AI, content, digital PR, and the changing world of search.

Heather went because search is evolving quickly and we want to make sure we’re not just reacting to the latest AI hype we’re learning directly from people testing these changes, comparing them against what we’re seeing in our own client data, and figuring out what is actually worth putting into practice.

Meet Wil Reynolds

Wil Reynolds Women in Tech SEO Fest Philadelphia 2026 Talk on "AI Forward vs. AI Foolish: How I See People Losing Brand Trust for Speed & What to Do About It”

One talk that particularly resonated, “AI Forward vs. AI Foolish: How I See People Losing Brand Trust for Speed & What to Do About It” came from Wil Reynolds, founder of Seer Interactive. He’s also one of the industry’s longtime voices on the future of search, having spoken on more than 100 conference stages worldwide, including MozCon and SearchLove.

The Forward Approach to AI

Wil approached AI with some of the same skepticism as Team BlueHuki. His talk focused less on chasing the newest technology and more on the question I think matters to businesses: Is all of this actually making us better marketers and helping more customers choose us?

Not that the technology wasn’t impressive, but we’ve been in digital marketing long enough to see technologies become surrounded by hype very quickly. Wil joked that some of the same people telling him to go all-in on AI had previously been hyping crypto and NFTs. His response was to slow-play it.

What eventually changed his mind wasn’t the hype around AI. It was realizing that AI solves a real problem with the way we search today: friction.

Traditional Search Trained Us How to Use It

Google trained us to translate the way we think into search-engine language. We type something like “real estate 19123,” even though that’s probably not how the question sounds in our head. Then we click through results, close pop-ups, skim multiple websites, compare information and assemble the answer ourselves.

As Wil put it,

“The job to be done was never to go to a bunch of webpages. The job to be done was to get a good answer.”

AI can do much of that assembly for us. We can ask a question the way we actually think about it, get an answer, add context and keep refining it. That reduction in friction is a compelling reason to believe AI will change how people search.

But Wil immediately added an important qualifier: we are still in the early innings.

That distinction matters because it’s also what we’re seeing at BlueHuki.

Prepare for AI Search without abandoning what works today

We’re actively tracking AI visibility, testing AEO strategies and watching how platforms like ChatGPT influence customer discovery, but we’re also looking at what happens after someone discovers a business.

Right now, we see relatively few conversions attributable to AI compared with Google and traditional search.

That doesn’t make AI unimportant. It means businesses need to be careful about putting tomorrow’s expectations ahead of today’s customer behavior.

If Google Search, paid search, local search, reviews, email or other established channels are producing customers, it would make little sense to pull significant resources away from them simply because AI is receiving more attention. A winning internet strategy needs to do two things at once: continue capturing the demand that exists today while preparing for the way discovery is changing.

This is where Wil’s talk became much less about AI technology and much more about marketing.

Never Lose Sight of Marketing Basics

Wil’s concern is that marketers have been given an incredibly powerful tool for doing more and our first instinct has often been simply to make more.

More articles. More pages. More “best” lists. More “top” lists. More programmatic SEO content.

He challenged marketers to search their own sites for titles containing words such as “best” and “top” and consider how much content we’ve created primarily because we thought an algorithm would reward it.

AI can now accelerate that approach exponentially. But should it?

Visibility Doesn’t Build a Brand by Itself

Wil used the example of restaurant recommendations. If you’re visiting Philadelphia and looking for a great restaurant, would you trust a recommendation from a source with genuine restaurant expertise like Michelin, or a programmatically generated “best restaurants in Philadelphia” page from a company with no meaningful connection to restaurants?

The second page might rank. It might even find its way into an AI answer.

But that doesn’t mean anyone believes it.

That’s where Wil’s framework of Seen, Believed, Chosen becomes useful.

Digital marketers have historically been very good at measuring Seen. We track rankings, impressions, clicks, traffic and share of voice. Now we’re adding AI mentions and citations to that list.

Those metrics matter, but they’re measures of visibility not necessarily business success.

The real customer journey continues after someone encounters a brand. They have to find enough evidence to believe the company is credible, and then enough reason to choose it over the alternatives.

This is also why Wil has been looking beyond traditional search metrics at things like branded search, direct traffic, referrals, newsletter subscriptions and ultimately conversion data. His point isn’t that these are replacements for SEO metrics. It’s that they can tell us something visibility metrics can’t: whether we’re actually winning people over.

That raises a harder measurement question.

What is the KPI for Trust?

This may be the question from Wil’s talk that marketers like BlueHuki and client should spend the most time on.

If our KPI is the number of articles published, AI can help us dramatically increase it. The same is true of pages created, words written and even queries where we’re visible.

But what if we’re increasing all of those numbers while producing a brand that looks and sounds exactly like everyone else?

Make More Memorable Content

Wil challenged the audience to think about what would happen if even 10% of our work were memorable.

That’s a much more useful challenge than simply trying to make every piece of content bigger or faster.

Memorable work could be original research, a genuinely useful resource, a strong perspective, an experiment, proprietary data or something good enough that an industry publication chooses to share it.

Wil talked about looking at referral and human-driven channels differently. If an industry publication sees a hundred pieces of content and decides yours is the one worth showing its audience, that isn’t simply another referral in Google Analytics. A human curator has effectively put some of their credibility behind your work.

That is much closer to a measure of trust.

For marketers, the actionable question becomes: Are we measuring only how often we’re appearing, or are we also looking for evidence that people believe we’re worth paying attention to?

The Best Uses of AI in Marketing Go Beyond Content Creation

This leads to what we think is one of the best uses of AI in marketing: helping us understand customers at a scale that previously wasn’t practical.

AI’s greatest marketing value may not be its ability to write another blog post.

It may be its ability to help us understand customers at a scale that previously wasn’t practical.

Wil discussed using large datasets, analytics, search queries and AI analysis to identify patterns. His broader work at Seer has also explored using AI to extract subject-matter expertise and understand the much longer, more nuanced prompts real people use when making decisions.

That creates a very different workflow.

Instead of asking AI, “Write me an article about X,” we can use it to help analyze what customers are asking, what sales teams are hearing, which content people trust, what competitors are known for and where our own brand lacks evidence.

Then humans decide what deserves to be created.

In other words, use AI to make the thinking better before using it to make the production faster.

Test the future without betting the business on it

Toward the end of Wil’s talk, he told marketers to stop fighting over predictions and simply:

Test it. Try it. Figure it out.

As a scientist-turned-marketer, that’s probably the part Heather agreed with most.

There are a lot of definitive predictions being made about AI search right now for something that is still changing rapidly. We don’t need to decide today whether Google will dominate search five years from now or whether AI platforms will replace it.

We need to run experiments that help us make better decisions now.

Practical Ways to Use AI to Improve Your Brand Online

Track whether your brand appears in AI answers. Look at how AI describes you and your competitors. Test whether changes to content affect that visibility. But don’t stop there.

Follow those users as far through the customer journey as your data allows. Compare AI traffic with organic search, paid search, referrals and direct traffic. Look at engagement and conversion rates. Watch branded search. Measure leads and revenue.

Then adjust investment based on what you learn.

SEO vs AEO in 2026

For most businesses today, we don’t think the answer is SEO or AEO. It’s maintaining the channels producing customers now while gradually building the authority and information AI systems need to understand and recommend the brand.

Perhaps most importantly, don’t allow the ease of producing content with AI to convince you that producing more content is automatically progress.

AI Should Make Us Better Marketers, Not Just Faster Marketers

Wil’s talk was ostensibly about AI, but I left thinking it was really about something much older: great marketing.

Technology can change how people find us. AI can remove friction from search. It can make marketers faster and give us entirely new ways to understand enormous amounts of information.

The fundamental progression Wil described hasn’t changed: People have to see you, develop a reason to believe you and ultimately choose you.

The opportunity isn’t to throw everything we’re already doing away and chase AI. We’re too early for that, and the conversion data doesn’t support it yet.

The opportunity is to use AI to become better marketers while continuing to measure the thing that matters most: whether all that visibility ultimately helps the business get chosen.

Put AI to Work Without Losing the Human Element

One of my biggest takeaways from the WTS Fest talks was that the goal shouldn’t be to use AI to simply produce more. The opportunity is to use it to understand customers better, uncover patterns in our data, capture real human expertise and make smarter marketing decisions.

Checklist for the Best Uses of AI in Marketing 2026

So we turned those ideas into a practical Best Uses of AI in Marketing Checklist for 2026. Use it to evaluate how your team is using AI today and whether that work is actually helping your business become more found, trusted and chosen.

This article reflects Dr. Heather Pressler’s takeaways from Wil Reynolds’ “AI Forward vs. AI Foolish: How I See People Losing Brand Trust for Speed & What to Do About It” presentation at WTSFest Philadelphia 2026, along with our perspective from applying and measuring AI in client marketing at BlueHuki.

Get Agency Help Getting Found & Chosen Online

Ready to build a marketing strategy that wins now and prepares you for what’s next? At BlueHuki, we don’t chase trends. We test them against real business results.

In 2025, 86% of our clients have increased their online visibility, and our strategies have generated 40+ million impressions and more than half a million visits for the businesses we serve. We combine SEO, AEO, paid media, content and reputation strategies to help exceptional businesses get found, trusted and chosen online. Schedule a quick connect with BlueHuki to propel your growth.

Similar Posts